- Eddins, John William, Jr.25
- Steely, John E.25
- Trotter, J. Carroll (Julius Carroll), 1917-200925
- Kehukee Primitive Baptist Association24
- Virginia Portsmouth Baptist Association24
- Carlton, John W., 1920-23
- Copeland, E. Luther, 1916-23
- Original Mayo Primitive Baptist Association23
- Drummond, Lewis A.22
- Tull, James E.22
- Blackmore, James H.21
- Brown, Raymond Bryan21
- Columbia Baptist Association (Va.)19
- Rogers, Max Gray, 1932-19
- Hendricks, Garland A. (Garland Alford), 1913-200318
- Martinsville Primitive Baptist Church18
- Miles, Delos18
- Miller, Glenn T., 1942-18
- Country Line Primitive Baptist Association17
- Green, J. Leo (James Leo), 1912-199417